Jamie Fuller was a talented artist and chef who had an innate ability to connect with people. She is missed by her family and friends.
In 1991, 16-year-old Jamie Fuller killed his on-again, off-again girlfriend, Amy Carnevale. Fuller then hid her body in Shoe Pond. The crime garnered national attention and spawned a Lifetime movie.
A Story of Redemption
A remarkably resilient individual, Fuller has forged an extraordinary narrative of redemption. During his incarceration and parole eligibility, he seized every opportunity to educate himself and confront his past, emerging as a fundamentally changed person. Today, he continues to advocate for criminal justice reform and athlete welfare.
A longtime yellow journalist, Fuller possesses an uncanny ability to marshal sensuous details through verbal language. The Dark Page, which serendipitously re-emerges as a reissued novel at the same time that his first three films are getting new audiences, demonstrates just how adept he was at capturing grit in print before he ever picked up a camera.
Fuller’s first film, I Shot Jesse James, tries to wring the same kind of evocative texture from his subject that Jesse James himself did, but it never succeeds. There’s a sense of the era in this tepid Western, but it isn’t as strong as it could have been.
But when he encounters feisty reporter Lance McCleary on the streets of Portageville, Fuller realizes that he is a magnet for trouble. The young man’s fervor and the jaded ruthlessness of his mentor, newspaper editor Carl Chapman, draw him into the story.
The next day, Fuller met Carnevale at the house of one of his friends and took her to a wooded area where they separated. Her friends later attested that they heard her screaming, and Fuller confessed that he covered her mouth, told her he loved her, and stabbed her in the stomach and back until she was dead. He then threw her into Shoe Pond.
He was convicted of her murder, but in 2002, the convictions were overturned, and he was released from prison. He has been living in a District housing project since his release and he lives with his 14-year-old son, who is autistic. He is an elder at the Let the Truth Be Told Ministries church in Portageville, where he teaches Bible studies and helps out with children’s activities.
He also works as a maintenance worker at a nearby manufacturing plant and is on dialysis for kidney disease. But he has found a measure of peace with his mother’s death, and he hopes to continue building a better future for himself and those around him.
Building a Better Future
The story of Jamie Fuller reflects the extraordinary potential for transformation within the human spirit. Her journey was forged against a backdrop of adversities, and the twists and turns of her early years would set the stage for the challenges that were to come. Educational obstacles and peer pressures were among the forces that conspired to steer her astray, but despite these difficulties, she continued to demonstrate an innate ability to connect with others.
It was her natural gift of empathy that drew people to her and enabled her to build lifelong relationships based on love and genuine kindness. Her friendships were built on an unwavering commitment to personal and professional improvement, as well as an unrelenting desire to support those around her.
Her culinary talents were also a source of joy and fulfillment for those closest to her. She loved to experiment with new recipes and create meals that nourished and brought delight to her family.
As her parole eligibility date drew closer, Jamie’s determination to make the most of her second chance became increasingly pronounced. Her steadfast beliefs in the power of rehabilitation and personal growth helped her to regain control of her life, and to emerge from prison as a fundamentally changed individual.
In 2019, at the age of 43, Fuller became eligible for a parole hearing. This pivotal point marked the conclusion of a 26-year sentence, and the beginning of a remarkable chapter of resilience and transformation.
Jamie’s emergence from behind prison bars was a testament to the transformative power of hope and the enduring strength of the human spirit. In the years since, she has used her experiences to help others on their own path of redemption and to advocate for criminal justice reform and athlete welfare.
She leaves behind an immense void that will never be filled, but her legacy will continue to shine brightly in the hearts of those she touched. We are all grateful to her for the gifts she shared with us, and we pray that she finds eternal peace.
Embracing a Second Chance
In 2019, after more than 26 years behind bars, Jamie Fuller reached a pivotal milestone — his parole hearing. The event marked a significant milestone on his journey of redemption and transformation. It was a chance to showcase his profound changes and a commitment to making a positive impact on the world around him.
A student at Beverly High School in Massachusetts, Jamie Fuller was a well-known member of the football team and a popular high school guy. However, his inner world was a dark place — a vicious cycle of jealousy and possessiveness. People who knew him described him as a control-freak who always wanted things his way, and who would fly into a rage at the slightest provocation.
On August 23, 1991, Jamie lured 14-year-old Amy Carnevale to his house and stabbed her in the stomach. When she tried to flee, he cut her throat. The murder was so brutal that it became a made-for-television movie and attracted national attention.
After the killing, Fuller did not express any remorse or guilt at trial or during his appeals. He told his friends that they would be next if they said anything to police. Despite this, his friends did not testify against him. They did, however, help him cover up the crime by tying her body with trash bags and cinder blocks and throwing it in Shoe Pond.
Following his conviction, Fuller has refused to show any remorse for his actions or for the impact on our family. He has not expressed remorse in our presence, and instead he has used his time behind bars to pursue various legal challenges and even attempt an escape from prison.
This story of tragic infatuation and lethal aggression highlights the power of young infatuation to spiral into destructive behavior. However, it also serves as a powerful reminder that there are many paths to redemption and a second chance. The horizon of parole and reintegration into society is a moment of hope and a promise for a more fulfilling future. Jamie carries with him a deep sense of purpose and a strong desire to make the most of his second chance.
Embracing Advocacy
Jamie Fuller’s story of redemption has illuminated the potential for change within prison walls. As he prepares to emerge into society, he is not only embracing his own second chance but also ensuring that others will follow suit. His tireless efforts to promote positive social impact and champion ethical practices in sports are fueling the flames of change.
Despite growing up in challenging circumstances, Jamie Fuller had a innate ability to connect with people. Her genuine kindness and infectious smile would brighten the lives of those she touched. Her spirit will live on in the hearts of her friends and family.
In 2019, at the age of 43, Jamie Fuller became eligible for a parole hearing after 26 years behind bars. The momentous occasion was not only a legal milestone but the culmination of a lifelong journey of personal transformation and self-discovery.
Fuller’s story of redemption is rooted in the challenges that he faced throughout his early years, including educational obstacles and peer pressures. His path eventually led to involvement in criminal activities, which he used as an escape from the realities of his challenging environment. These experiences, combined with missed opportunities for intervention, contributed to his encounters with the criminal justice system.
In the summer of 1991, Fuller murdered his on-again/off-again girlfriend, Amy Carnevale. This tragic event was immortalized in a Lifetime television film, “No One Would Tell,” which highlights the fact that several of Jamie’s friends knew about his tumultuous relationship with Amy and his threats to kill her, but no one tried to intervene.
During his time in prison, Fuller embarked on a profound journey of personal growth and self-discovery that would ultimately lead to redemption and inspiration. Upon his release, Jamie devoted himself to pursuing advocacy work to advance the causes of criminal justice reform and athlete welfare. He has since inspired countless individuals, both inside and outside of prison walls, demonstrating that redemption is possible and that personal transformation knows no bounds.
